So why do some people favour them, why did it take so long for a belly putter to win a major, and as an amateur golfer should you try a belly putter?
Belly Putter / Long Putter / Broomstick Putter – is there a difference?
In a word – YES.
The long putter and the broomstick putter are one and the same thing and are longer than a belly putter – typically around 50 inches and is anchored to the sternum.
The belly putter is anchored just above your navel and is typically around 40 inches long.
The reasons for using a belly putter or a long putter over a traditional ‘short’ putter are actually the same, so for the rest of this article unless I specifically mention it, when I say ‘Belly putter’ I am also talking about ‘Long putters’.
A short history of the belly putter
- The first belly putter was patented by Richard T Parmley in 1960.
- Phil Rogers was the first golf pro to use a belly putter in the late 1960’s.
- The long putter was first introduced in the early 1980’s.
- Johnny Miller was the first golf pro to use a long putter.
- During the 1980’s and 1990’s belly putters gained more popularity with many golf pros such as Sam Torrance, Bernhard Langer, Tom Lehman, Vijay Singh and Adam Scott.
- In 2009 Angel Cabrera wins the US Masters with a belly putter (although used unconventionally).
- In 2011 Keegan Bradley wins the US PGA with a belly putter (conventionally used).
Why was the belly putter invented?
A number of golf pros suffer from what is called putting ‘yips’. The ‘yips’ is quite a complex area in its own right but the most common effect is that golfers literally freeze over a putt and cannot even take the putter head away from the ball – they are unable to
control the muscles needed to execute a putting stroke. They can manifest themselves in other ways and although the outward affect is a physical one, many golf gurus believe it starts from a psychological issue (e.g. having to hole a 2 foot putt to pay the mortgage!).
The yips have been the downfall of many fantastic golfers including Adam Scott and Bernhard Langer but luckily they have battled through and belly putters have helped them enormously. Unfortunately many golf pros have quit golf due to the yips.
However – many have overcome the yips, and many of them by switching to a belly putter.
How does a belly putter help golfers with the yips?
Firstly, let me say that belly putters are not an instant cure to the yips! But they can definitely help. Simplistically it’s because the muscles used with a belly putter are less prone to freezing – as I’ve mentioned in my golf putting lessons it’s much easier to control the big muscles than the small muscles. With a belly putter you use far fewer of the smaller muscles so are far less prone to the yips.
Are there other benefits to using a belly putter?
Yes there certainly are – a couple of big ones!
The wrists are virtually removed from the putting stroke therefore they cannot ‘break down’ during the putting stroke – a common problem on pressure putts.
Since your hands are not gripping the club but more ‘guiding’ the club head there is less chance for a wrong grip or for you to twist the putter (although it’s still possible).
One great advantage of long putters is when you are taking relief and have two club lengths. This is one area that I think the rules could be tightened up by simply saying ‘No putters are to be used’ since it is outside the spirit of the game (in my opinion).
Also your stance is more upright so it puts less pressure on your back – this only really applies to practicing your putting since 30 or so putts in a round shouldn’t be troubling you.
Are there any dis-advantages with belly putters?
Again there certainly are…
The biggest problem is that you have less feel so judging pace is a lot harder.
Another problem (more so for amateurs) is that they take a long time to get used to.
Finally – again more so for amateurs – fitting them into the back of your car can be tricky!
So what is all the fuss about with belly putters?
Many people claim that they are against the rules of golf that state a club must not be anchored against the body.
This of course depends how you use a belly putter. As mentioned in the history Angel Cabrera won the 2009 US Masters with a belly putter but didn’t anchor it against his navel – so in my opinion he was not breaking the rules. In 2011 Bradley Keegan used the belly putter in a ‘conventional’ way and had it anchored against his navel – which in my opinion is strictly illegal.
Other people claim it gives golfers an unfair advantage – but if that were the case we’d all be using them, and many more tournaments would have been won with them, so I am not buying that argument!
Should amateur golfers try a belly putter?
Some amateur golfers suffer from the yips so it may be worth a go. But please remember that everything else is the same. You still need to read the green, judge the pace and of course strike a sweet putt.